Thrufeed Centerless OD Grinding: Parameters and Troubleshooting

On many work parts, the outside diameter (OD) needs to be highly accurate. Tight tolerances are required for OD size, roundness, high and low frequency lobe patterns and taper. Thrufeed centerless OD grinding can achieve precise part quality at an economical processing cost.   

William Bednarski, Application Engineer, Saint-Gobain Abrasives

The original article was published in Cutting Tool Engineering Magazine, February 15, 2017.  

 

Overview

As the name implies, centerless grinding involves the grinding of cylindrical parts without locating the part on a specific center line between centers. The centerless process is commonly used for high volume production, and it’s also easily used for low volume production because the machine setups are fairly simple. 

In thrufeed centerless OD grinding the workpiece passes between two wheels, a grinding wheel and a regulating wheel (as illustrated in the diagram, right). Both wheels rotate in the same direction, but at much different speeds. The purpose of the grinding wheel is to remove material from the workpiece and improve part OD quality. The regulating wheel acts like a brake, controlling the rotational speed and thrufeed rate of the workpeice. An angular-topped workrest blade supports the workpiece as it passes through the grinder between the grinding and regulating wheels.

Centerless grinding - angular topped blade setupProper setup of centerless grinding with angular-topped blade, work above center of wheels.

The abrasive types used in the grinding wheel are determined by the part material to be ground. Aluminum oxide, ceramic aluminum oxide and CBN grains are typically used to grind ferrous materials. Silicon carbide and diamond grains are typically used on non-ferrous materials. These grains are used in vitrified or resin bonds to make a grinding wheel. Generally vitrified bonds are used to grind “weak” configured parts that may deform when high grind force is applied. Resin bond grind wheels are used to grind stronger parts like bars or solid rollers.

Regulating wheels are made in rubber, plastic or vitrified bonds. Some applications like tapered rollers use special shaped, hardened steel regulating wheels.

Machine Setup Parameters

  1. Top angle on workrest blade.
  2. Relationship of the part center height above the wheel’s centerline dimension with the regulating wheel diamond dresser offset dimension.
  3. The regulating wheel angle of inclination or work feed angle to the regulating wheel dresser angle.
  4. Entrance/exit guide alignment.
The top angle on the workrest blade helps with the rounding action of the part. With increased angle, quicker rounding occurs, but it also weakens the blade rigidity. The most common top angle used in centerless grinding is 30 degrees. As the diagram below indicates, lower angles are used when grinding heavy workpieces, which help minimize vibration. Workrest top angles typically range from 45 degrees down to 20 degrees. Generally speaking, 30 degrees is a good starting point for the majority of parts to be thrufed centerless ground. Centerless grinding - typical top angle on workrest

A majority of centerless grinders are set up with the work center height above the centerline of both wheels. There are some applications like bar grinding that set up the bar center below the centerline of the wheels to keep bar vibration low during the grinding process. We will focus on setups with the work center above the centerline of the wheels, which is commonly called “work height above center.” Part diameters 1½" or less should have the height above center dimension set at half the part diameter. Parts greater than 1½" should be proportionally less for stability reasons. The purpose of the truing device on the regulating wheel is to have the diamond follow a similar line of contact to the wheel that the parts will follow. This will allow parts to enter and exit the grind zone in a straight line. So there is an important relationship that ties the work height above center dimension to the regulating wheel diamond offset setting. (See images below.)

Centerless grinding - angle relationships Centerless grinding - angle of inclination

Typically the diamond offset is set slightly less than the workpiece height above center dimension. It is key to understand that this relationship influences the grind pattern and part contact to the grinding wheel as parts pass through the grinder. It is very important to calculate the ratio of the regulating wheel diameter to the workpeice diameter, or D/d. “D” is the regulating wheel diameter and “d” is the workpeice diameter. Once you know this ratio, then you can use the “Truing Setting” chart (below) to determine the correct truing angle and diamond offset.

Truing Angle Setting
  6° 10' 6° 10' 6° 20' 6° 25' 6° 30' 6° 35' 6° 45' 6° 50' 6° 55' 6° 55'
  5° 15' 5° 15' 5° 25' 5° 30' 5° 35' 5° 40' 5° 45' 5° 55' 5° 55' 5° 55'
Work 4° 20' 4° 25' 4° 30' 4° 35' 4° 40' 4° 40' 4° 50' 4° 55'
Feed 3° 30' 3° 30' 3° 35' 3° 40' 3° 45' 3° 45' 3° 50' 3° 55'
Angle 2° 35' 2° 40' 2° 40' 2° 45' 2° 50' 2° 50' 2° 55' 2° 55'
  1° 45' 1° 45' 1° 50' 1° 50' 1° 50' 1° 55' 1° 55'
  50' 50' 55' 55' 55' 55' 55'
RATIO D/d   3 3.5 4 5 6 7 12 18 24 48
  1/8" 7/64" 7/64" 7/64" 7/64" 7/64" 1/8" 1/8" 1/8" 1/8" 1/8"
  1/4" 7/32" 7/32" 7/32" 15/64" 15/64" 15/64" 15/64" 1/4" 1/4" 1/4"
Work 3/8" 21/64" 21/64" 11/32" 11/32" 11/32" 23/64" 23/64" 23/64" 3/8" 3/8"
Height 1/2" 7/16" 7/16" 29/64" 29/64" 15/32" 15/32" 31/64" 31/64" 1/2" 1/2"
Above 5/8" 35/64" 35/64" 9/16" 37/64" 37/64" 19/32" 19/32" 39/64" 5/8" 5/8"
Center 3/4" 21/32" 21/32" 43/64" 11/16" 45/64" 45/64" 23/32" 47/64" 47/64" 47/64"
  7/8" 3/4" 49/64" 25/32" 51/64" 13/16" 53/64" 27/32" 55/64" 55/64" 55/64"
  1" 55/64" 7/8" 29/32" 59/64" 15/16" 15/16" 61/64" 63/64" 63/64" 63/64"
Diamond Set-Over

 

The regulating wheel angle of inclination typically is in the +1 degree to +3 degree range. This angle, along with regulating wheel speed (RPMs), determines the part thrufeed rate in inches per minute. This setting also affects the distance a part will travel in one workpiece revolution. A lower angle means a shorter travel distance and this affects grind force on the workpeice. So you can affect how a grinding wheel performs by changing regulating wheel inclination and regulating wheel RPMs. Parts that have a high diameter-to-length ratio, such as bearing rings, should have a lower regulating wheel angle of inclination to help keep the parts stable as they travel through the grind zone. Proper settings allow the workpieces to smoothly enter and exit the grind zone.

Typically there are adjustable guides on the entrance and exit sides of the grind machine. The purpose of the guides is to align the workpeices as the wheel goes in and comes out of the grind zone. (See diagram, right.) It is important to correctly align the guides located on the regulating wheel side. The workpeices should smoothly transition between guides and regulating wheel. Even a slight “bump” during the transition can cause a defect to be ground into your parts. Centerless grinding - work diameter before grinding

Proper guide alignment is important to avoid your parts from having a “barrel” or “hour glass” diameter across the part length. The illustration below shows how misaligned guides could affect part quality.

Proper centerless grinding guide alignment - avoid barrel Proper centerless grinding guide alignment - avoid hourglass

Be sure to inspect all the tooling used in the centerless grinder, and make sure all tooling is in good condition. You can have a good machine setup, but if the diamond tools are worn, they will cause dull dress condition on your wheels and generate poor part quality. Paying close attention to your tooling condition and machine setup will ensure that your grinder will produce excellent part quality at low manufacturing costs.

Share: